Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between S Hotel Montego Bay and Hotel 39 Jamaica? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort is the best fit for your next getaway.
Best for travelers who want a stylish boutique hotel on the Hip Strip with direct beach access, a rooftop bar, and a modern design-forward atmosphere steps from Montego Bay's dining and nightlife.
Better for travelers who want a smaller, more intimate boutique property in Montego Bay with a quieter pace and personalized service.
If you want a design-forward boutique hotel on the Hip Strip with beachfront access, a rooftop bar, and walkable proximity to Montego Bay's best restaurants and nightlife, S Hotel Montego Bay is typically the better pick.
If your priority is a smaller, more intimate boutique experience with a quieter atmosphere and personalized attention, Hotel 39 Jamaica may be the better match—particularly for travelers who prefer a lower-key pace.
Bottom line: choose S Hotel Montego Bay for Hip Strip energy, beachfront style, and modern amenities, and choose Hotel 39 Jamaica for a more intimate, quieter boutique stay.
| Category | S Hotel Montego Bay | Hotel 39 Jamaica |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe |
Modern boutique hotel on the Hip Strip with beachfront access, rooftop bar, and a design-forward atmosphere that blends style with walkable convenience.
Best for Hip Strip Access
|
Smaller, intimate boutique property with a quieter pace and personalized service for travelers who prefer a more low-key Montego Bay experience.
Best for Intimacy
|
| Location | On Gloucester Avenue (the Hip Strip), steps from restaurants, bars, and Doctor's Cave Beach in the heart of Montego Bay. | In Montego Bay with a quieter positioning, suited for guests who want to be near the action but not directly in it. |
| Rooms & Suites | Contemporary rooms with modern finishes, some offering ocean views and balconies—designed with a boutique-chic aesthetic. | Intimate room options with a simpler style, ideal for travelers who prioritize value and personalized service over design details. |
| Dining | On-site restaurant and rooftop bar with Caribbean-inspired cuisine and craft cocktails, plus easy access to Hip Strip dining. | More limited on-site dining, with proximity to local Montego Bay restaurants for off-property meals. |
| Pool & Beach | Beachfront pool with direct Caribbean Sea access—ideal for guests who want both pool lounging and beach time in one setting. | Pool amenities available, though the beach experience may require traveling to nearby public or hotel beaches. |
| Atmosphere | Social and stylish with rooftop energy, suited for travelers who want a boutique hotel that feels lively and connected to Montego Bay. | Quieter and more personal, better for travelers who want a calm retreat without the bustle of a larger property. |
| Price & Value | Best value if you want Hip Strip location, beachfront amenities, and modern style in a boutique package. | Best value if you prioritize intimacy, personalized attention, and a lower-key boutique experience. |
Rooms at S Hotel Montego Bay feature contemporary design with clean lines and modern finishes, creating a boutique-chic atmosphere that complements the hotel's Hip Strip location.
S Hotel is the better pick if you want a polished, Instagram-ready room with direct access to Montego Bay's best stretch.
Hotel 39 Jamaica offers more intimate accommodations with a simpler, understated style suited for travelers who value comfort and personalized service over design flourishes.
If you prefer a no-frills boutique stay with attentive service and a calmer pace, Hotel 39 may suit your style.
Dining at S Hotel Montego Bay centers on Caribbean-inspired cuisine and craft cocktails, with a rooftop bar that offers sunset views and a social atmosphere.
Expect:
Hotel 39 Jamaica offers more limited on-site dining options, making it better suited for travelers who plan to explore Montego Bay's local restaurant scene.
If you want rooftop drinks and on-site dining convenience, S Hotel is the stronger choice.
S Hotel Montego Bay offers a beachfront pool with direct Caribbean Sea access, giving guests the best of both worlds—pool lounging and beach time steps apart.
Hotel 39 Jamaica provides pool amenities on property, though beach access may require a short trip to nearby public beaches or beach clubs.
If beachfront access is a priority, S Hotel Montego Bay is the clear winner.
S Hotel Montego Bay sits directly on Gloucester Avenue—the famous Hip Strip—putting you steps from Montego Bay's best restaurants, bars, and nightlife.
Hotel 39 Jamaica offers a quieter positioning in Montego Bay, suited for guests who prefer a more peaceful base while still being within reach of local attractions.
If you want to walk out your door and be in the heart of the action, S Hotel is the better fit.
S Hotel Montego Bay offers the most value when you want Hip Strip location, beachfront amenities, modern design, and rooftop atmosphere in one boutique package.
Hotel 39 Jamaica is the better value if your priorities are intimacy, quiet, and personalized attention over location and amenities.
Choose S Hotel if you want walkable access to Montego Bay's best restaurants, bars, and beaches with a stylish boutique atmosphere.
Hotel 39 is the better pick for travelers who want a smaller, quieter boutique property with personalized service and a calmer pace.
For travelers who want direct beach access and a beachfront pool, S Hotel delivers both in one stylish package.
If you want a more affordable boutique option and don't need beachfront amenities, Hotel 39 offers an intimate alternative.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for S Hotel Montego Bay:
